“You might cry, you might not,” says playwright Sarah Ruhl in the show notes of Writers Theatre’s revival of her 2003 play ‘Eurydice’. Under new Artistic Director Braden Abraham, there’s a youthfulness in both casting and staging that feels like a big breath of fresh air for the Glencoe theatre company. Sarah Ruhl’s whimsical dialog appeals to a childlike sense of wonder and her bittersweet version of this classic story may unlock parts of yourself hidden away by grown-up practicalities.

We all know the Greek mythology of Orpheus and Eurydice in which a man tries to bring his beloved bride back from the dead with the sound of his music. If he can avoid looking back at her, she can follow him out of the underworld. Easier said than done.

Sarah Ruhl’s play borrows the names and framework of the Greek tragedy, but her quirky adaptation is aimed at a modern audience. In the twenty years since this play was written, Sarah Ruhl has become a regular fixture of contemporary theatre and has been shortlisted for the Pulitzer. Her unique style of balancing small-scale spectacle with arrestingly poetic observations about life is what continues to make her work popular with audiences.

‘Eurydice’ is immediately endearing because of the well-honed aesthetic created by Braden Abraham and scenic designer Courtney O’Neill. Minimal staging makes big moments like an elevator that rains all the more theatrical. Solid casting, especially in the lead roles, makes this production even more loveable.

Sarah Price plays the title character with Kenneth La’Ron Hamilton as her Orpheus. The pair are impeccably styled by Danielle Nieves. Chic fashion combined with great chemistry, it’s nearly impossible to keep your eyes off. Price is perfectly charming throughout and shows a lot of range. Her co-star is equally compelling and together they make a good case for enduring love.

There’s a line in the play at Eurydice and Orpheus’ wedding in which she says, “Weddings are for fathers and daughters.” With that idea in mind, Ruhl richly draws Eurydice’s father into the underworld, and they get to reconnect in the afterlife. These are some of the play’s most emotionally charged moments. John Gregorio plays the role of her father barefoot and vulnerable in a way that men of a certain age are rarely written. It’s here that Ruhl veers from the source material and allows this play to really be an examination of her own life.

As the playwright said, you may cry, you may not, but you will leave with a romantic feeling. Between the spectacle created on stage and the full swath of emotions illicited by the cast, there’s a lot to unpack. Sarah Ruhl’s play has aged well and it’s exciting to see one of her earlier works done to such incredible standards at a theater not far from where she grew up. Writers Theatre’s production feels like a full-circle moment in this decorated playwright’s career.

For tickets and/or more show information, click here.