
Black Button Eyes Productions has announced it will follow up its hit co-production (with City Lit Theater) of STRANGE CARGO: THE DOOM OF THE DEMETER with Conor McPherson's fantasy drama ST NICHOLAS, in June and July. Storefront theatre stalwart Kevin Webb will perform the one-actor, darkly comic drama of an unnamed Dublin theatre critic whose figurative penchant for drawing blood with his reviews takes a turn when he becomes involved with a group of real-life vampires in suburban London. One of McPherson's earliest produced plays, ST NICHOLAS premiered in London in 1997 and was staged in New York off-Broadway in 1998. THE NEW YORK TIMES' Ben Brantley called it "a delectably droll celebration of storytelling as striptease...Mr. McPherson combines old-fashioned yarn-spinning skills with a canny grasp of the frayed contemporary psyche." The opening will be Saturday, June 27 at 7:30 pm, following a preview on June 26, and will play through July 26 at City Lit Theater, in the historic Edgewater Presbyterian Church at 1020 W. Bryn Mawr Avenue.
Kevin Webb has been one of the most prolific actors of the Chicago storefront theater scene, with over 50 credits – eight of them with Black Button Eyes - since arriving in Chicago from Mississippi in 2009. He is an ensemble member of Trap Door Theatre and a Jeff Award winner for his portrayal of Sweeney Todd with Kokandy Productions.
The production team for ST. NICHOLAS includes Liz Cooper (Lighting Design), Rachel Sypniewski (Costume Design), Jeremiah Barr (Set/Props design and Technical Direction), Joe Griffin (Sound Design), and Carrie Hardin (Dialect Coach).
Tickets for ST NICHOLAS are $30,00 plus fess for all performances and are on sale now at https://stnicholaschicago.eventbrite.com .
LISTING INFORMATION
ST NICHOLAS
By Conor McPherson
Directed by Ed Rutherford
Starring Kevin Webb
June 26 – July 26, 2026
Preview Friday, June 26 at 7:30 pm
Thursdays – Saturdays at 7:30 pm, Sundays at 3:00 pm
No performance Saturday, July 4. Additional performances Monday, July 13 at 7:30 pm and Saturday, July 18 at 3:00 pm.
City Lit Theater, 1020 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Chicago
Tickets $30 plus fees on sale now at https://stnicholaschicago.eventbrite.com .
This is a play about theater critics. And this is a play about vampires. But we repeat ourselves. In this darkly humorous one-person show by Conor McPherson, a former Dublin scribbler spins the tale of his unfortunate encounter with the supernatural.
BIOS
Kevin Webb (he/him, performer) is oh so happy to be returning to Black Button Eyes. He has been seen in their productions of SHOCKHEADED PETER, MARY ROSE, CORALINE, NEVERMORE, NIGHTMARES & NIGHTCAPS, DR. HORRIBLE'S SING ALONG BLOG, AMOUR and WHISPER HOUSE. Chicago credits: TITANIC THE MUSICAL (MARRIOTT); SWEENEY TODD, INTO THE WOODS AND JEKYLL & HYDE (Kokandy); SWEENEY TODD and THE IRISH...AND HOW THEY GOT THAT WAY (Porchlight); THE PRAGMATISTS — Poland and Chicago, THE KILLER, MOTHER COURAGE and THE RESISTIBLE RISE OF ARTURO UI (Trap Door); THE SECRET GARDEN (Court); A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC and SWEENEY TODD (Theo Ubique); THE PITCHFORK DISNEY (Interrobang); THE VIEW UPSTAIRS (Circle); MARIE CHRISTINE (BoHo); SONGS FROM AN UNMADE BED, ANGRY FAGS and DESIGN FOR LIVING (PrideArts). Kevin is a proud member of the Trap Door Theatre ensemble and spends most days walking dogs around Chicago.
Ed Rutherford (he/him, Director) is the Producing Artistic Director of Black Button Eyes Productions, where directing credits include STRANGE CARGO: THE DOOM OF THE DEMETER, GHOST QUARTET (Jeff Nomination: Director of a Musical), EVIL DEAD THE MUSICAL (Jeff Nomination: Director of a Musical), SHOCKHEADED PETER, DR. HORRIBLE'S SING-ALONG BLOG, AMOUR, GOBLIN MARKET, and CORALINE, as well as his scripts NIGHTMARES & NIGHTCAPS, A SHADOW BRIGHT AND BURNING, and MARY ROSE (Jeff Nomination: New Work). Promethean Theatre Ensemble: artistic associate, where he directed THE LIAR, his adaptation of Peter S. Beagle's THE LAST UNICORN, THE CAUCASIAN CHALK CIRCLE and BEYOND THERAPY. Book & Lyrics: the parody musical MURDER, REWROTE and MARY ROSE. As an actor, he's performed with City Lit, Drury Lane Oakbrook, Porchlight, Theater Wit and many others. A graduate of Northwestern's theater program, he also completed his MBA at Kellogg. ed-rutherford.com.
Conor McPherson (Playwright) is a celebrated Irish playwright, screenwriter, and director, best known for his intimate, conversational plays that frequently blend naturalism with the supernatural, exploring themes of guilt, regret, and redemption. His international breakthrough came with THE WEIR (1997), which won the Laurence Olivier Award for Best New Play. Other major acclaimed works include ST. NICHOLAS (1997), DUBLIN CAROL (2000), SHINING CITY (2004)—nominated for a Tony Award for Best Play—and THE SEAFARER (2006). In 2017, he wrote and directed the Bob Dylan musical GIRL FROM THE NORTH COUNTRY, which found critical success on the West End and Broadway.
ABOUT BLACK BUTTON EYES PRODUCTIONS
Black Button Eyes Productions' mission is to bring to Chicago premieres and seldom-seen works containing elements of fantasy, in which the magical and surreal invade reality. The company has mounted 14 productions since its founding in 2014, including STRANGE CARGO: THE DOOM OF THE DEMETER (co-production with City Lit Theater), A SHADOW BRIGHT AND BURNING, MARY ROSE, DR. HORRIBLE'S SING-ALONG BLOG, MASQUE OF THE RED CORONA VIRUS, WHISPER HOUSE, GHOST QUARTET, EVIL DEAD: THE MUSICAL, NIGHTMARES AND NIGHTCAPS: THE STORIES OF JOHN COLLIER, NEVERMORE: THE IMAGINARY LIFE AND MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF EDGAR ALLAN POE, SHOCKHEADED PETER, AMOUR, and GOBLIN MARKET, and CORALINE. Black Button Eyes Productions is led by Producing Artistic Director Ed Rutherford.
Brendan Coyle is no Mr. Bates when it comes to his latest stage endeavor. Instead, the Olivier Award-winning actor, best known for his role on Downton Abbey as the likeable, mild-mannered, ever so loyal valet to Lord Crawley – Mr. Bates, takes on a persona far removed from what most of us are accustomed to seeing him portray. In Goodman Theatre’s ‘St.Nicholas' Coyle plays an resentful, cynical theatre critic with an unbelievable story to tell. Coyle's performance commands audience attention from beginning to end without a moment otherwise.
The first couple minutes of the monologue play are already filled with intensity. Coyle doesn’t even have to utter a single word as he tosses handfuls of rice in various areas of his disheveled apartment – chairs overturned, windows plastered in old newspaper. It looks like the place was ransacked. After penetratingly staring out to the crowd, he finally takes a seat and begins to tell his story. Upon revealing that he is a theatre critic (which alone in itself conjures a hearty, collective laugh in the way he says it), he admits he has been harsh in his reviews due to jealousy. He is a powerful critic. His reviews can make or break a production. The first act offers a great amount of depth into his character in a gripping monologue that only playwright Conor McPherson could pen. The description of his life as a critic laid out so well and superbly delivered, we get a perfectly painted picture. We feel his frustration, his pain and his triumphs. We feel for the character. In true McPherson style, who has given us such powerful productions as “the Seafarer’ and ‘Dublin Carol’, the play is filled with dark humor, plenty of F-bombs, drinking and, of course, deep soul searching.
“When I was a boy, I was afraid of the dark… What was there. And maybe one of the things I thought was there was vampires,” our critic says in the first act. It’s not the only mention of vampires in the play’s first half. Though riding along with perfectly timed moments of humor, “St. Nicholas” becomes more of a psychological thriller as it progresses. The Dublin theater critic tells us how he gave up his everyday life for a beautiful actress, an actress whose spellbinding grace, beauty and charm won him over while reviewing a play he planned to trash. As he describes the actress, it is obvious there is no turning back in his mind. His obsession, he reveals, leads him to strike a deal with a community of modern-day vampires and that’s when we are taken on a journey like none other, as we hang on his every word.
The second act takes place in a candlelit setting – almost presenting an atmosphere like that of a ghost story told around a campfire as we are given the devilish details of his interactions with the band of vampires. Candles burn on the window sills, his desk, the floor. There is no stage lighting directed to Coyle’s face. Instead, the glow of small flames flicker about, allowing just the perfect amount of lighting to most effectively create just the right ambiance as he tells his dark tale. Peter McKintosh does a masterful job with set design and Matt Daw with lighting while Simon Evans' direction is flawless.
Towards the end of his magnificent story Coyle's character then wonders if it was real or just a dream. “After all, what is a dream and what is real?” he then asks while offering several scenarios of which can so be defined as a "dream". Perhaps, as he suggests, our dream moments are real and what we perceive as our awake moments are in fact dreams. The play, after all, is inspired by McPherson’s own dream - where he was bitten by a vampire and given two pain killers.
Emmy Award nominated Brendan Coyle is outstanding. He is a true stage presence and has the ability to reach out to his audience in the most effective of ways – a true master of the stage.
I wholeheartedly recommend ‘St. Nicholas’ at Goodman Theatre as Coyle’s performance is not to be missed – enthralling, powerful and perfectly executed humor – a theatrical delight. Catch this limited engagement that comes direct from London's internationally renowned Donmar Warehouse.
‘St. Nicholas’ is being performed in Goodman’s cozy 350-seat Owen Theatre through January 27th. For tickets and/or more show information, visit www.goodmantheatre.org.
Spaceman: Into the Quiet Terror of the Void
Inside a Real ‘Fire House’ You Are Immersed in Phantasmic Lives of Firefighters
Spamalot Is Every Monty Python Fan’s Dream Come to Life
Raven Theatre announces the 2026-27 season
Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.